Nikita Scherbak sat. Scherbak got demoted. Scherbak got hurt. He got promoted. Scherbak got waived and claimed. Scherbak didn’t fit. He was too poor on defence for the 4th line. Not potent enough attacking to play higher. It might have occurred to Charles Hudon that Scherbak’s journey might be his, soon enough. Hudon’s problem isn’t today, but it could be soon. Look at the depth chart:
Drouin – Domi – Shaw
Tatar – Danault – Gallagher
Byron – Kotkaniemi – Lehkonen
Hudon – Peca – Deslauriers
Agostino – Chaput
IR: Armia
The club has control or contracts for the entire top 9. Where’s Hudon’s path for promotion?
Flip Hudon for Shaw. Does that look right? Not really. Shaw isn’t as good as Bergevin thinks. But Shaw has things Hudon doesn’t. Shaw annoys. Shaw scores enough to play up or down in the lineup. He’s also been a positive possession guy for years. Hudon doesn’t do as much.
In 72 games last year, Hudon scored 10 goals and 30 points, shot the puck 179 times, and was a positive possession guy, playing about 14 minutes a night. Looks ok. Maybe give him 3 more minutes a night and he’ll get closer to 200 shots a season.
Then Pacioretty became Tatar. Galchenyuk turned into Max Domi. Kotkaniemi got drafted. Looks like the only thing that can reasonably move Hudon up the lineup is injuries or more trades. Now Hudon’s playing 11 minutes a night. He’s on track to take about 60 fewer shots this season. Now he’s a negative possession player. He’s looking more like he’s out the door than going up the lineup.
The above is why you see Hudon’s name on this list. Unless things change soon, it’s more likely to be a waiver claim. Or for a late round pick. I give it till the end of this season. Ryan Poehling and Nick Suzuki are 2017 1st round draft picks. Poehling is big. Poehling is improving. He might leave college after this season. Suzuki shoots the lights out. He’s too good for junior. There’s no guarantees for youth in the NHL. But then, there’s no guarantees for middling veterans either. Does Hudon have a role with this team? He isn’t a consistent possession guy who kills penalties like Armia. He’s not a two-way guy like Lehkonen. He probably won’t become a better scorer than the other top-9 guys.
Plants need water and sunshine. Attacking forwards need ice-time and offensive linemates to put up points. Hudon’s only spot is the fourth line. For now. So it’s a question of when, and for how little he’s traded for.
Professional hockey-watchers can disagree, but Hudon and Scherbak demonstrate some mild mismanagement by failing to showcase players. Bergevin’s called up players like Agostino and Chaput while Julien’s played Deslauriers whenever he’s had a chance. Those three work hard, but are all at least 26 years old and easily obtained as free agents or for late round draft picks. Julien plays them to make the team better now. The Canadiens aren’t real contenders this season, though. Their priority should be figuring out who to keep and to maximize value for players they don’t need. So, as Julien leaves them out of the lineup or reduces their ice time, guys like Scherbak and Hudon lose any value they might have had either from their high draft selection or their strong AHL performances. Hudon or Scherbak probably won’t become great players elsewhere, but that doesn’t mean the Canadiens’ only choice was to give them less ice time. The Canadiens might have tried a sweet trick that the Arizona Coyotes used a few years ago on Mikkel Boedker.
The trick worked like this: In 2015-2016 with Boedker’s contract expiring, the Coyotes threw him out on the powerplay as much as possible to juice his stats. Averaging 3 minutes and 53 seconds of powerplay time a game ranked Boedker 9th in the entire league for average power play time, just above players like Claude Giroux, Sidney Crosby, and Evgeni Malkin, and just behind powerplay quarterbacks like Kris Letang, Shayne Gostisbehere, and Brent Burns. That is absolutely insane and his name sticks out like a sore thumb on that list. But it worked out, as the non-contending Coyotes off-loaded Boedker on the Colorado Avalanche for then-first round prospect Conner Bleackley, third round pick prospected Kyle Wood, and Alex Tanguay. Of that group, only Kyle Wood might still become something. At the time of the trade, however, that was a lot to give up for, at best, a middle-six forward with consistently poor puck possession and limited offensive upside.
A contender can’t afford to play a middling offensive player on the first unit powerplay. But the Canadiens need to figure out their priorities. Saying the Habs are contenders in 2018-2019 is saying they’ll make the playoffs over a youthful Buffalo. And then you’re saying that they’ll get past the in-their-prime Leafs and Lightning. Good as they look right now, Agostino, Chaput, and Deslauriers won’t make that happen. Maybe they’ll keep it up and prove me wrong. Till that’s borne out, they definitely create a roster-crunch that’s already claimed Jacob De La Rose and Nikita Scherbak.
Hudon’s next.